Jeanne Dunning: Tom Thumb: Notes Towards A Case History

In her photographic work, Jeanne Dunning has frequently started with familiar and seemingly innocent objects (mundane body parts, fruits or vegetables), and transformed them into the unfamiliar and the suggestive. For her first web-based project, Tom Thumb: Notes Towards A Case History, Dunning again begins with something familiar -- a fairy tale. By drawing our attention to particular elements of the story and bringing in eccentrically related historical research, Dunning implies a reading of Tom Thumb's tale that is idiosyncratic, suggestive, and weirdly compelling. The artist leaves the viewer pondering distinctions between fact and fiction and perhaps wondering which is more fascinating.

Assembled by Dunning from sources dating as early as the 15th century, Tom Thumb: Notes Towards A Case History presents Tom Thumb's story as it was told before certain elements, perhaps considered inappropriate for children, or simply distasteful, were elided from the tale. Dunning's version includes episodes in which Tom is regurgitated by a giant, inadvertently swallowed and defecated by a cow, and is thwarted in his attempt to ravish the queen. She also includes a collection of related anecdotes that weaves together the recurring motifs of Tom's story while evidencing some rather remarkable coincidences. For example, at one point in Tom Thumb's story, he is swallowed by a wolf then cut out of its stomach. Hence, Dunning tells us of a man named Tom and his doctors, Dr. Wolf and Dr. Wolff, who contributed to medical history by studying the hole in Tom's body that led directly to his stomach. And we read that one of Freud's most famous case studies is about a man with life-long bowel problems who was afraid of being eaten by wolves. Copious illustrations from these widely varied sources visually reinforce the text.

To tie together these disparate narratives, Dunning employs a rebus, a device most frequently found in children's stories, in which pictures are substituted for words. The words thumb, throat, stomach, bowels, hole, wolf, cow, and fish are sometimes replaced with brief animations that serve as links to key places in the site's other narratives where those words occur, allowing the reader to jump from one story to another. These animations are of hand shadows or shadow puppets. The use of hands, appropriate to a story about a man named after a thumb, also recalls Dunning's series of photographs of hands creating cave-like spaces that suggest other bodily orifices.

Dunning's interest in the divisions (or lack thereof) between the inside and the outside of the body drew her to the Tom Thumb story. Tom's epic travels repeatedly take him into throats, stomachs, and bowels as he re-enters and escapes from the inside of the body. For anyone acquainted with Dunning's Puddle photographs which picture bodies covered with oozing flesh-colored liquids, the image of Tom running home to his mother covered in bodily fluids will seem oddly familiar.

By inviting us to look at Tom's story as a case history, Dunning suggests parallels between Tom's life and the stages of infantile development described in psychoanalytic theory. She traces Tom's journeys through the oral, anal and phallic stages, his repetition compulsion, and finally his arrival at the Oedipus complex. Dunning relates how recipes from the 14-16th centuries use the terms stomach and womb interchangeably, reinforcing the notion that Tom's repeated return into stomachs is a misguided attempt to return to the womb. Tom stays trapped in these infantile stages of development until, after finding himself aroused by the queen, he attempts a more direct path towards his goal. However, instead of successfully negotiating the Oedipus complex and so growing up, Tom's grappling with the Oedipal stage precipitates his death.

During the six months following the project launch, tiny excerpts from Tom's case study will spill into the margins of Dia's main web site, an appropriate space considering the diminutive and marginal stature of our hero. Continuing Dunning's practice of blurring borders, these transgressions may confuse visitors looking for information about the museum. Hopefully, however, visitors will be intrigued enough to follow these teasers straight into the heart of the project, a detour with serendipitous discoveries. In this sense, Tom Thumb: Notes Towards a Case History is a microcosm of the unsuspected journeys we take while surfing the web, as we make our way through massive amounts of information where truth is often stranger than fiction

Jeanne Dunning

Selected One-person Exhibitions

Feigen Contemporary, New York

Bodybuilder & Sportsman, Chicago

Tomio Koyama Gallery, Tokyo
James Harris Gallery, Seattle, WA
Magazin4 Vorarlberger Kunstverein, Bregenz, Austria

The Konstmuseet, Malmö, Sweden

Galleria Massimo de Carlo, Milan

Richard Telles Fine Art, Los Angeles

Anthony D'Offay Gallery, London
Galerie Samia Saouma, Paris

Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden, Smithsonian Institution, Washington D.C.; traveled to The Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago
Feature, New York

Illinois State University Galleries, Normal, Illinois

Real Art Ways, Hartford, CT

Feature, Chicago

Selected Group Exhibitions

New Photography 14, Museum of Modern Art, New York, NY

Tenth Biennale of Sydney, The Art Gallery of New South Wales,Sydney, Australia

Identity and Alterity, Venice Biennale, Venice, Italy
Feminin-Masculin, Centre Georges Pompidou, Paris, France

The Whitney Biennial, The Whitney Museum of American Art, New York, NY


Agboten-Jumeau & Jean Charles, Forum International, September 1991, pp. 83 & 92
Aletti, Vince, Village Voice, February 1, 2000, p.91
Barak, Ami, Art Press, October, 1991, p. 119
Camhi, Leslie, Village Voice, February 15, 2000
Gerstler, Amy, Artforum, November 1990, pp. 174-75
Holliday, Taylor, ArtNews, February 1999, pp.94-95
Kirshner, Judith Russi, Artforum, September 1992, pp. 102-3
Perchuk, Andrew, Artforum, April 2000
Seward, Keith, Artforum, January 1995, pp. 85-6.
Viegener, Matias, Art Issues, December 1990, p. 43
Wittig, Rob, Art in America, January 1991, pp. 142-43
Yood, James, Artforum, September 1996, pp. 114-115

Sara Tucker

Bookmark and Share